Reviewing Whatever VS Beatrix

[Deleted]

Thread Here

Whatever
VS
Beatrix


----

Who do you think won the Round 2?

Decision Date: September 2nd

[size=5][b]Facts|Style|Sportsmanship[/b][/size]

[size=3][i]System[/i][/size][blockquote][b]Facts:[/b] [blockquote]Explanation - [Winner][/blockquote]

[b]Style[/b]: [blockquote]Explanation - [Winner][/blockquote]

[b]Sportsmanship:[/b] [blockquote]Explanation - [Winner][/blockquote]
[center]Overall Winner[/center][/blockquote]

[Deleted]

I am Lilo Pelekai and I’m judging the match between Whatever vs. Beatrix.
Facts|Style|Sportsmanship System

Facts:

Wow that was INTENSE! I’m mad it didn’t transcend farther; that could’ve been the most exciting match yet! I guess I’ll have to stick around more to see what else that could happen here.

Factually speaking it was pretty awesome; to think that technology can easily turn the tide to dominate the beginning of the match. I’ll have to give it to Beatrix for taking a shot to the arm. Sure a deliberate shot to the arm was harsh, but it was INSAAANE to try to do it again; I guess in the games anything is a go. And if it works and put you at an advantage, why fix it?

But we all must admit the highlight was the destruction of the Saloon. Hey, it was a ballsy move, but you gotta do what you gotta do.

[Tie]

Style:

It’s kinda sad the round was short lived, since we were literally WAITING for it to continue to see if Whatever would make it out of that mess. Who would’ve thought just an environmental change can make one maneuver, so combusting.

[Beatrix]

Sportsmanship:

The sportsmanship went both way from having a clean straight bullet wound to having a portion of the 2nd floor collapse on you. Sure, he softened the blow, but come one…it was…a building, a building. A BAR with stuff…

[Tie]

I guess if I do simple math I’ll have to give it to

Beatrix

Can I get her autograph? That was soooo AWESOOOOOOME! I need to get one of those rifles. Pew Pew Pew.

[Deleted]

Facts|Style|Sportsmanship

System

Facts:

I'll go through these quickly if you don't mind. Fact checking, most seemed to work out in everyone's favor, although I disagree with Beatrix use of Climhazzard. Climhazzard only fires its secondary effect upon a successful first strike, which should be up to the other player, but Beatrix made the assumption Clim would hit. Couple that with the use of two strikes within the same action when each strike should have been given its own action, I declare the winner [Whatever]

Style:

Both had very nice styles, Whatever going for an all out offensive and Beatrix biding her time and making her marks when it was most effective. Although halfway though the battle Whatever was struggling to regain his feet, I took special heart in Beatrix use if defensive play, opting not to use any actions in favor of simply waiting and biding her time. It was a smart move on the general's part, and I rather enjoy her decision a lot. [Beatrix]

Sportsmanship:

This was very close when I think about it. Beatrix took a straight out shot to the arm that changed her tactics and strategy, which was quite different from her previous battle. Whatever, on the other hand, did have an entire second floor saloon fall on top of him. Good on Beatrix not kicking him while he was down. In my opinion, it would have been out of character for her to do so. Fair play wins both ways here, so I'll have to chalk this up to a tie. [Tie]

Can't decide a winner, unfortunately, so I'm gonna leave this at a tie.

 

[Deleted]

Facts|Style|Sportsmanship

System

Facts:

Both used their abilities well. They understood how their skills worked in the environment and used them in a realistic (for a fantasy setting) manner. The two were contrasted starkly in their ability access. While Whatever had access to both long ranged weapons and short ranged, Beatrix was limited to primarily close range. Had it continued in such a way I feel Beatrix was met with complications due to the sheer number of long range skills in Whatever's arsenal. - [Whatever]

Style:

The new, unknown, environment put both opponents on even ground. They used their abilities in smooth succession and had responses as accordance to their character's personalities: eg Beatrix unleashing powerful attacks, forgetting her skills are quite powerful ad in Whatever's case he wasted a large spell to simply clear debris with disdain of his situation. Whatever held true to his battle style, and Beatrix kept her Paladin's nature, but I felt Beatrix was a bit off her game due to the fact she failed to consider her environment when using Climhazzard, making the action sloppy in tactical terms.- [Whatever]

Sportsmanship:

Both behaved with deliberate understanding that this was a match and they were not out there to slaughter the other. Whatever was determined to win, but he still was capable of banter with his opponent. Beatrix was courteous and apologized for her err concerning her close ranged attack within the confines of the saloon. - [Tie]

Whatever succeeded in 2/3 brackets. I select him as the overall victor.

[Admin]

Facts|Style|Sportsmanship

System

Facts: A

Alright after reading this the facts are simple. Beatrix used a lot of her actions to cure herself and move into wait. Whatever was on the offensive and made most of his attacks toward non-vital organs. Beatrix may have brought down the Saloon (which was kinda funny) but he still did the most damage in my opinion. The final unresolved post with Wahtever making a few attacks. [Whatever]

Style:

I have to say that Beatrix probably lead this battle by the fact Whatever had to keep chasing her. Beatrix would move the location and wait it out for the heartless to follow. It was hard to decide, but I think Beatrix led it and won with style. - [Beatrix]

Sportsmanship:

I have to give this section to Whatever. He'd been rather open with his attacks, in character. Beatrix seemed a little awkward being on the defense. But I guess it's understandable. He seemed to use them to the best of his ability and didn't just avoid the building collapsing on him and he just cast an ability and took the brunt of it. - [Whatever]

Overall Winner
Whatever